The Daily Shot And Data - February 9, 2016
What started as a crude oil driven selloff in the equity markets has quickly evolved into fears around the global banking sector. Why? Here are some trends that help explain the situation.
1. Bank jitters started with Portugal’s bank called Novo Banco which was restructured forcing haircuts on senior bondholders (including Blackrock and Pimco). As analysts had suspected for some time, European senior bank bonds are not really "senior" and are in fact subordinated to depositors. The Novo Banco event brought this issue to light. Moreover not all senior bonds were treated the same. Only bonds carrying a minimum denomination of €100,000 (institutionally held) were hit. After such an event, why would any institution ever buy a senior European bank bond?
2. Bad loan balances at some European banks continued to rise. Italian banks looked especially shaky and starting in 2016 Italian bank selloff accelerated.
Source: @MarkTOByrne
3. Sovereign wealth funds of many oil producers hold significant amounts of financials shares. With fiscal situations strained, dumping public shares is a quick way to release some of those petrodollars. This is one of the links back to oil.
Source: @Schuldensuehner
4. As bank shares sold off, some became concerned about capitalization. The focus shifted to the so-called CoCos (contingent convertibles) which became a popular way in Europe to raise tier-1 capital. The securities are treated like bonds and therefore don't dilute existing shareholders. In an adverse event a regulator can force CoCos to be converted to equity - providing additional capital cushion. Now that some have raised questions about capitalization, investors became concerned about CoCos shutting off coupons in order to preserve capital. In such a situation investors are effectively short a put on the bank but are not collecting any premium (coupon). So they headed for the exists.
Source: @ericbeebo
By the way, here are the top CoCo issuers.
Source: Financial Review
Note that Pimco even created a fund to buy CoCos and similar securities.
Source: Google
5. The market especially focused on Deutsche Bank which had its first year of losses since the financial crisis. Many investors have been calling for a major restructuring at the bank for some time. With the CoCos getting hit (chart below) and shares selling off to new lows (second chart below) investors became concerned about DBs stability.
Source: @anilvohra69, @FT
Deutsche Bank (Frankfurt listed) shares
DB CDS spreads spiked.
Source: @lemasabachthani
Moreover, the CDS spreads on subordinated debt hit new records.
Source: @GuyJohnsonTV
What's particularly troubling is that DB's CDS spread is approaching that of UniCredit, a major Italian bank.
Source: @marcel_lucht, @KarelMercx, @FT
This uncertainty has spilled over into the broader financial sector - here are a couple of examples.
1. European financials.
Source: Ycharts.com
2. Japan bank shares (TOPIX bank index ETF)
Source: Google
In fact, here is Nomura. While Japan's banks are somewhat shielded from the full impact of negative rates, some reserves generated by QE going forward will have a negative impact on profitability.
Source: Google
Here are the senior and subordinated debt CDS spreads on European financials (in aggregate).
Source: Bloomberg.com, @business
One concern about this renewed pressure on banks is that it could reignite the Eurozone stability fears. For example, Greek shares fell to the lowest level since 1990 as bank shares lost almost a quarter of the value in one day.
Eurozone periphery government bond yields rose in response to these new concerns, with spreads to Bunds jumping. Here is the situation with Portugal.
Source: Investing.com
Source: @business
Eurozone core and other major economies saw their government bond yields moving sharply lower.
Source: Investing.com
Source: Investing.com
For the first time in history, the Japanese 10-year government bond yield moved into negative territory.
With the 10y JGB yield now negative, we are clearly above $6 trillion of negative yielding government bonds.
Source: @FT (this is before the 10yr JGB yield became negative)
Here is the 5yr JGB yield.
Continuing with Japan, the yen had a sharp rally, regaining its status as a "safe haven" currency (for a while the euro had that status). Dollar-yen is now back to 2014 levels, reversing a great deal of work the BoJ did to weaken the yen.
Chart shows the US dollar falling against the yen over the past week
A much stronger yen, combined with the pressure on Japan's banks, sent the Nikkei sharply lower.
Source: Investing.com
Back in the United States, the 5yr treasury yield fell to the lowest level since 2013. What happened to those rising rates we've been promised?
The treasury curve flattened further with the 10y-2y treasury spread now at levels not seen since early 2008.
Source: @SoberLook
With all the negative rates around the world (discussed above), the option-implied probability of negative rates in the US is on the rise.
Source: @business
The market-implied probability of a March Fed rate hike fell to zero.
Source: @Not_Jim_Cramer
And here we have the market-implied probabilities of Fed rate hikes in 2016. Now there is an over 70% chance of "one and done". This is likely to damage the Fed's credibility.
Source: @SoberLook, CME
As discussed yesterday, the HY markets remain shut, especially for the more leveraged names. Here is quarterly issuance. More on this later.
Source: Duff & Phelps
Some leveraged credits should be ready to throw in the towel. Chesapeake Energy is one of those as the equity loses a third of its value in a day and short-term bond yields spike to new highs.
Source: Google
Source: @JavierBlas2 @Chesapeake
US equity markets remain under pressure, with NASDAQ down 3% intraday.
Here are a couple of other developments.
1. After being the darling of the investment world, biotech shares are being dumped.
Source: Ycharts.com
2. We have capitulation in US momentum shares. The chart shows relative performance of momentum stocks vs. the S&P500.
Source: stockcharts.com
3. Twitter shares fell below $15 for the first time - what a disaster.
Source: Ycharts.com
Here is what's going on in the commodities markets.
1. For the first time in months gold touched $1,200/oz.
Source: barchart
2. Wholesale gasoline futures are trading below 96 cents per gallon.
Source: barchart
3. Related to the above, the average US diesel price dropped to $2.008 a gallon, the lowest in nearly 11 years.
4. Global oversupply of wheat is pressuring US wheat futures again.
Source: barchart
Source: @WSJGraphics, @WSJ
Finally, after all the scary trends above, let's end on a positive note. Ireland's consumer confidence hit a multi-year high. Impressive.
Source: Investing.com
Turning to Food for Thought, we have 3 items this morning:
1. 23% of Americans watch the Super Bowl for the commercials. Amazing.
Source: @StatistaCharts, h/t Jake
2. Based on consumer surveys, the tech industry could be facing tough times ahead.
Source: @StatistaCharts, h/t Jake
3. VCs continue to plow money into tech.
Source: @PitchBook, h/t Jake
Sign up for Sober Look's daily newsletter called the Daily Shot. It's a quick graphical summary of topics covered ...
more